Celebrating our 20th season!! Now accepting Visa, Mastercard and Apple Pay at all locations.

Baked Indian Pudding

Available Sizes:

Single | Double | Triple | Home Run | Pint | Quart

Step up to the plate with our Baked Indian Pudding ice cream! Inspired by the classic Maine dessert, this flavor captures the rich taste of molasses, milk, and cinnamon. Every scoop is thick and creamy, delivering a warm, comforting flavor reminiscent of New England’s tradition.

Whether you’re swinging for the fences or enjoying a slow day, this flavor will always score big!

Stay in the Lineup!

Don’t miss a single scoop! Join our email lineup for the latest flavors, specials, and insider news straight from the Fielder’s Choice dugout.

By clicking Sign Up you’re confirming that you agree with our Terms