Hitting Ice Cream Homeruns since 2006
At Fielder’s Choice we strive to “hit for the cycle” EVERYDAY! We want our customers to enjoy amazing ice cream, at an unbeatable value, delivered with exceptional customer service.
Fielders Choice (FC)
(feel-drz choys) noun
A play in baseball made on a ground ball in which the fielder chooses to put out an advancing runner instead of the batter.
Open year Round
In Maine, we know the love for ice cream isn’t limited to summer. No matter the season, count on us to serve your favorite scoops.
Cash-Only at All Locations
We keep things simple and classic, just like our ice cream. We accept cash only, but don’t worry—ATMs are available for convenience!
Fielder’s Choice is more than just ice cream
It’s a family-owned dream that began in 2006 in Sabattus, Maine.
From the very beginning, our focus has been on crafting the finest quality ice cream right in each of our stores, ensuring a fresh and creamy experience in every scoop. Although we’ve won numerous awards for being the best in Maine, our true reward is the joy we bring to each customer.
Celebrating 19 years of serving up smiles and unforgettable ice cream experiences.
With 6 locations and counting, we’re bringing our delicious ice cream closer to you!
Truly the best place to get ice cream in the state of Maine. Excellent service and great prices. My family and I have been customers for years and have never been disappointed.
Our Story: More Than Just Ice Cream & Baseball
Fielder’s Choice started as a small family venture and has grown into a Maine staple, loved by both locals and tourists alike. Through years of dedication, we have created a community-centered ice cream haven where memories are made over heaping cones and delightful sundaes.
Our commitment to quality, value, and friendly service has earned us a reputation as one of the top ice cream destinations in the state.
Visit Us: Create Your Sweet Tradition
Ready to make your own sweet memories? Stop by one of our six locations and indulge in our homemade treats.
Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, we can’t wait to serve you and make you a part of our Fielder’s Choice family. Because here, every scoop is a home run!
What Makes Us Different?
At Fielder’s Choice, we believe in creating ice cream that stands out. We serve massive portions at an affordable price, ensuring you get the best value for your treat.
From our family-friendly atmosphere to our creative menu offerings, we aim to provide an experience as sweet as the ice cream we serve.
Crafted for Creamy Perfection
Something for Everyone
We craft our ice cream in-house, offering both classic and unique flavors, along with dairy-free options. With our homemade brownies and cookies, there’s truly something for everyone to enjoy.
Stay in the Lineup!
Don’t miss a single scoop! Join our email lineup for the latest flavors, specials, and insider news straight from the Fielder’s Choice dugout.
By clicking Sign Up you’re confirming that you agree with our Terms
Franchise Opportunities: Step Up to the Plate
Bring the joy of our ice cream to your community. Explore how you can own a Fielder’s Choice franchise!
Be Part of our Passionate Winning Team
Looking to scoop up a fun and rewarding job? Become part of our passionate ice-cream-loving team!
Pitch Us Your Questions, Comments, Or Ideas
Questions, comments, ideas, or just want to say hi to the team? Drop us a line— or just swing by and Say hi!